Egregore - Group Dynamics in Religion.
Egregore
is the term that I use in this paper to identify the concept of a
composite identity for a group in religious activities. Egregore may be
described as the group-mind and/or group-spirit of a body of people
engaged in a cooperative activity. In planning and leading group
activities and rites of worship the Drui should be aware of the
egregore, including, how to build, maintain and direct a healthy group
identity. In this paper I would like to briefly examine the concept and
role of egregore in the activities of Draiocht and the role of the
Druid as religious leaders in managing egregore.
What I consider to be a healthy
egregore is based on a holistic model wherein it becomes an
independently identifiable and dynamic living thing that is more than
the sum of the parts and which exists with it’s own identity separate
from the identity of any particular member. There is also an egregore
model which I would consider generally unhealthy wherein the group-mind
is actually just an extension of the identity of a single leader, and
which is a common characteristic of what I would consider to be a
harmful cult. Egregore can be constructively developed and
intentionally guided or it can be allowed to develop without active,
intentional guidance in a natural dynamic fashion. Egregore can also
develop in a haphazard and unbalanced way in which it is allowed to
lose dynamics and become a static thing which becomes mentally,
emotionally and/or spiritually paralyzed. It is my opinion that
egregore should be consciously developed and maintained in order to
keep it healthy and functioning in a well balanced and actively dynamic
manner.
Size
of an egregore can range from two strangers who decide to pray together
and who will never see each other after one isolated time of spiritual
need, to large bodies of people who share membership in a specific
common spiritual identity. A small group of strangers may suddenly find
that they share a spiritual need and they may gather in prayer, this
sort of spontaneous small-group egregore can often be seen in times of
extreme crisis such as during disasters. At the other extreme end of
the spectrum is the massive grouping of people who are members of a
specific religious body which may spread to the ends of the Earth but
who share, through that membership, a common spiritual identity.
Between these two extremes of size fall many groups of differing sizes,
some may be contained within a living room while others need a large
building or field and still yet others spread across the boundaries of
nations.
Duration
of an egregore can range from the short lived group mind of people
gathered for a single activity to the extremely long-term identity of a
religious organization. Any time people gather for a coordinated
activity, even if that activity is a single event, some sort of
egregore is formed. An interfaith event such as a memorial may only
happen the one time but as those people gather and hear speakers and
participate in prayers their minds and emotions are being directed
toward a common focus and so an egregore develops. A short duration
egregore is generally felt as being spontaneous and generally is not a
highly planned thing. A long duration egregore develops with any group
that meets regularly or in which the participants share some sort of
common spiritual identity. It is in a long-duration egregore that
considerations or consistency and balance become of prime import. Be a
spiritual activity a single event bringing strangers together or be it
a long term spiritual group worshipping together repeatedly, it will
have some sort of group identity.
Formality
of structure and management of an egregore is a consideration that is
often linked to the combination of size and duration with both having
an effect on the need for formality. Generally, as a group becomes
larger in structure there is tendency toward more formality in how the
structure and organization is arranged. Duration also generally effects
the formality or structure and organization in a relative fashion in
which longer duration brings about greater formality. As groups
increase in size and duration they tend to develop formalized education
and standards for membership and leadership and often a centralization
of authority. These general principles are seen as tendencies and are
certainly not any sort of hard and fast rule there are many available
examples of massive groups of people attending a candlelight vigil with
minimal formality, just as there are long lasting organizations which
have little formality with no centralization of authority and even no
formal clergy.
Within
an egregore there are many relationships which effect the dynamic
balance. These relationships can be emotional, intellectual, physical,
spiritual, economic and/or familial, basically running the gamut of
human social structures. These internal relationships can strengthen,
weaken, unbalance, rebalance and even shatter an egregore. So within an
egregore an effort should be made to maintain balance in these internal
relationships as they effect the overall group, reducing the
consequences of interpersonal tension and difficulties, working toward
the goal of fostering supportive reciprocal interpersonal relationships.
An
egregore is going to have external relationships which must also be
considered. These external relationships exist between a particular
egregore and the world around it in how it relates to society as a
whole, the environment, deities and spiritual issues and to other
groups. Any given egregore may be a component part of a larger egregore
and so it will relate to that larger egregore in some fashion, for
instance a family may have a spiritual egregore and yet that egregore
is part of the larger egregore of the congregation in which they
worship which, in turn, may be part of an even larger egregore made up
of congregations joining together in a larger denominational body which
is, in turn, part of an entire religious movement. It is important to
consider how a group identity relates to all aspects of environment
from the immediate surroundings to the entire world be those
surroundings spiritual or mundane.
Participation
in an egregore is another important area of consideration in which we
identify who is included in or excluded from the group identity.
Methods of inclusion can be almost passive and as simple as the
presence of an individual in the activity or simple formal membership
in the group. Active inclusion methods are techniques whereby a person
does something or performs a task relative to the group identity and so
feels himself or herself to be doing something or filling a role. In
actuality almost any group will see many methods of inclusion at work
some of which are more passive while other methods are more active.
When
directing the egregore in ritual there are two main varieties of
technique, the passive techniques which are ‘presented direction’ and
the active technique which is ‘inclusive direction’ with examples of
each variety being seen in most rites. Presented direction is
considered to be passive on the part of the attendees because it
consists on the things being presented to them, while inclusive
direction is considered active on the part of the attendees because it
consists of things which they do or activities in which they
participate. Included in the area of presented direction are things
such as oratory, drama, incense, background music and the details
which set the stage or establish the atmosphere. In the area of
inclusive direction we see things such as chant, singing, dance, group
movement, group recitation, call and response and basically any
activity which includes the body of participants in the action.
A
final area of concern is that of the attitude of the leader toward the
egregore and his or her awareness of the egregore. The good leader will
consider issues of egregore and how to best direct activities and
energies to develop a healthy balanced group identity. The largest
danger in leadership is that the leader will at some point confuse his
or her personal identity with the aggregate identity of the group, this
is often the result of pyramidal leadership concepts in which the
leader is seen to be at the top or ‘in charge’ of the group.
Application of our concept of centrality to the paradigm of leadership
helps to prevent this because the leader is not seen as being at the
top of a pyramid but at the center of a group and so rather than being
the head that dictates he or she becomes the hub which holds the wheel
together and allows it to turn smoothly. The leader must remain aware
of egregore to allow him or her to direct it in a healthy direction and
to prevent any confusion between the individual identity of the leader
and the aggregate identity of the group.
Egregore
is the group mind or group spirit of a body of people gathered together
for common religious activities. Egregore can be either a healthy, well
balanced, nurturing spiritual identity or it can become an unbalanced,
damaging thing which is unhealthy for the participants. Issues of
egregore are to be considered as they are seen within a rite of worship
and as they are seen within the life of a spiritual congregation or
organization. A good leader intentionally directs egregore in a healthy
direction using a variety of methods of inclusion which range from the
passive to the active. A good leader makes every effort to keep his or
her own personal identity separate from the aggregate identity of the
group. Through good leadership an egregore can grow and thrive becoming
a healthy, well balanced, nurturing spiritual environment.